When a Firm Must File Form CRS: Dual Registrant and Affiliate Rules
SEC staff guidance clarifies when broker-dealers must file Form CRS, why state-registered advisers cannot share a filing, and when delivery is triggered without an account.
The short answer: a firm does not have to prepare or file a relationship summary if it has no retail investors to whom it must deliver one, and a firm cannot fold a state-registered investment adviser affiliate into a single Form CRS filing unless that affiliate has its own SEC filing obligation. According to the SEC staff guidance, delivery of Form CRS can also be triggered even when no brokerage account is opened.
These points come from SEC staff guidance on Form CRS, addressing electronic posting, the no-retail-investor scenario, dual registrant and affiliate filings, and the “check and application” mutual fund process.
The no-retail-investor case
The guidance opens with a direct question: what happens if a registered broker-dealer has determined it has no retail investors to whom it must deliver a relationship summary? The staff answer is that such a firm is not required to prepare or file a relationship summary. The trigger for the filing obligation is the existence of retail investors who must receive the disclosure, not registration alone.
For readers checking their own firm’s position, that distinction matters. A broker-dealer registration does not by itself create a Form CRS filing duty under the staff’s reading; the duty tracks whether there are retail investors entitled to delivery.
Why a state-registered adviser cannot join a dual registrant filing
The guidance sets up two scenarios. Firm A is an SEC-registered broker-dealer and a state-registered investment adviser. Firm B is an SEC-registered broker-dealer that also provides investment advisory services to retail investors through its affiliated state-registered investment adviser. The question is whether either firm may prepare and file a single relationship summary as a “dual registrant” or as an “affiliate” under Form CRS Instruction 5.
The staff says no in both cases. Firm A may not file as a dual registrant because, as an SEC-registered broker-dealer paired with a state-registered investment adviser, it does not meet the definition of a “dual registrant” in the Form CRS Instructions. For Firm B, the affiliated state-registered investment adviser may fit the definition of an “affiliate,” but that affiliate does not have a separate Form CRS filing and delivery obligation. As a result, Firm B may not prepare and file a single relationship summary with that affiliated state-registered adviser.
The general rule the staff draws from this is that affiliates should file a single relationship summary only where each affiliated entity has an SEC obligation to file. The test is the affiliate’s own regulatory obligation, not the corporate relationship.
What firms A and B must file instead
In these scenarios, Firms A and B must each prepare and file a relationship summary covering their brokerage services, and that summary must not exceed two pages. This keeps the filing tied to the entity that actually carries the SEC obligation.
The guidance does allow limited acknowledgement of other services. Firms A and B may each acknowledge other financial services they provide in addition to their SEC-registered brokerage services, including any state-registered investment advisory services, so long as presenting those services does not obscure or impede understanding of the information that must be in the relationship summary. Firms may also include a means of facilitating access to more information about those services, such as cross-references or hyperlinks.
The practical reading: added services can be mentioned, but the two-page brokerage summary must stay clear and complete. The allowance is for context and access, not for folding an out-of-scope adviser into the filing.
The “check and application” mutual fund question
The next scenario involves a broker-dealer that sells mutual funds to retail investors through a “check and application” arrangement, where the mutual fund is not held directly within a brokerage account. The question posed is whether the firm must file and deliver Form CRS when it does not recommend the mutual fund and does not open a brokerage account for a new or prospective retail investor.
The staff answer is that the Form CRS filing and delivery requirements under Rule 17a-14 apply even when a retail investor does not open or have an account with a broker-dealer but still engages in a securities transaction through the broker-dealer, such as buying a mutual fund through a “check and application” process. The absence of an account does not remove the obligation.
The follow-up question asks when delivery is triggered. Under these circumstances, the broker-dealer must deliver the relationship summary before or at the time it places an order for the retail investor. That timing point gives firms a concrete operational marker: the order placement, not account opening, is the delivery event.
How to read this guidance
Three decision points stand out for a firm checking its own filing and delivery position.
- Retail investors first. No retail investors to whom delivery is owed means no preparation or filing obligation under the staff’s answer.
- Affiliate filing requires an SEC obligation. A single relationship summary is appropriate only where each affiliated entity has an SEC obligation to file; a state-registered adviser without a separate Form CRS filing and delivery obligation cannot be included.
- Accounts are not the trigger. A securities transaction through the broker-dealer, including a “check and application” mutual fund purchase, can require filing and delivery, with delivery due before or at the time the order is placed.
These are staff answers to specific hypotheticals, not a rewrite of the rule text. A firm in a similar structure should map its own retail investor base and its affiliates’ SEC obligations before assuming a single filing is available.
What the source does not say
The guidance does not say that a state-registered investment adviser has no obligations of its own under state rules; it addresses the Form CRS filing and delivery obligation only. It does not provide a general template for combined filings, nor does it list every service that may be acknowledged alongside brokerage services beyond the state-registered advisory example. It does not address the content of the relationship summary beyond the two-page limit and the requirement that added services not obscure required information.
The source also does not state that electronic posting on “Doing Business As” websites is prohibited; it identifies that topic only as a heading, with no answer text provided in the material reviewed. And it does not give a compliance deadline or transition date for firms to adjust existing filings.
Sources
Informational only. Not financial, legal or investment advice. Check the primary sources listed above before you act on anything here.