Verifying an Exempt Offering Claim: What to Check
A claims-based checklist for checking whether an offering's stated exemption matches the SEC rules on solicitation, investor limits, Form D filing and intrastate limits.
The useful answer up front: when someone tells you an offering is exempt from SEC registration, you cannot verify that from the label alone. You verify it against the specific exemption named, because the SEC's own summary ties each exemption to different conditions: who can be sold to, whether general solicitation is allowed, dollar or investor limits, and whether a Form D notice must be filed.
The source page is the SEC's Exempt Offerings resource for small businesses. It states the baseline rule clearly: every offer and sale of securities must either be registered under the Securities Act of 1933 or rely on an available exemption from registration, most of which are listed on that page (c01). It also describes itself as a high-level summary chart (c02), which matters for how much weight you give it.
Start with the named exemption, not the marketing
A promoter saying "we're exempt" tells you almost nothing. Ask which exemption is being relied on, then check the conditions attached to that exemption in the source summary.
- Rule 506(b): described as private placements prohibiting general solicitation. It covers transactions by an issuer not involving any public offering and limits sales to no more than 35 non-accredited investors in any 90 day period (c03).
- Rule 506(c): described as a private placement permitting general solicitation. It permits general solicitation where all purchasers are accredited investors and the issuer takes reasonable steps to verify that the purchasers are accredited investors (c04).
- Rule 504: a limited offering of up to $10 million, permitting the offer and sale of up to $10 million of securities in a 12-month period and often used for regional multi-state offerings (c05).
- Rule 147 and Rule 147A: Rule 147 is a "safe harbor" under Section 3(a)(11), and the intrastate offering exemption under Rule 147A lets companies raise money from investors within their state without concurrently registering the offers and sales at the federal level (c12).
- Rule 701: exempts certain sales of securities made to compensate employees, consultants and advisors in a non-capital raising transaction and is not available to Exchange Act reporting companies (c13).
- Regulation Crowdfunding: enables certain companies to offer and sell securities on an internet based platform through an intermediary that is a registered broker-dealer or registered funding portal (c10).
- Regulation A: an exemption from registration for public offerings, although offerings made under it share many characteristics with registered offerings (c11).
Two of these are easy to confuse and produce very different checks. If an offering is pitched publicly, that public pitch is consistent with Rule 506(c) only if every purchaser is accredited and the issuer takes reasonable steps to verify accredited status (c04). Under Rule 506(b), general solicitation is prohibited and there is a cap on non-accredited investors within a 90 day period (c03). The same public promotion, in short, points to different conditions depending on the exemption claimed.
Check the Form D trail for any Regulation D claim
If the offering is described as a Regulation D offering under Rule 506(b), Rule 506(c) or Rule 504, the source states that a Form D notice is required and must be filed within 15 days after the first sale of securities in the offering (c06). That gives you a dated, checkable event rather than a general promise.
The source adds two practical details. The SEC does not charge any filing fee for a Form D notice or amendment (c07). And Form D notices and amendments must be filed online using the SEC's EDGAR system (c08). The source also points readers to a separate Form D frequently-asked-questions resource for more information (c09), which is where you would look for filing mechanics rather than on the summary page itself.
Worked example, clearly hypothetical
Suppose a company claims a Rule 504 offering and tells you it has already begun selling. Hypothetical: the first sale occurred on a given date, and the company says a Form D was filed. The source's 15 day window (c06) gives you the date arithmetic to check whether the described filing timing lines up. Hypothetical: if filing is claimed on day 5 after the first sale, that falls inside the stated window; if on day 40, it does not. This example is constructed to show the method; it is not a report about any real issuer.
For a Rule 504 claim, the dollar ceiling is also testable in principle: up to $10 million of securities in a 12-month period (c05). Hypothetical: an issuer describing $4 million raised in one 12-month window sits below that stated ceiling. Again, this is arithmetic on the source's figure, not an assertion about any offering.
Match the claim to the exemption's shape
Each exemption in the source has a recognizable shape, and a claim that does not fit the shape is a signal to ask more questions.
| Exemption claimed | Condition stated in the source |
|---|---|
| Rule 506(b) | No general solicitation; no more than 35 non-accredited investors in any 90 day period (c03) |
| Rule 506(c) | General solicitation allowed; all purchasers accredited; reasonable steps to verify (c04) |
| Rule 504 | Up to $10 million in a 12-month period (c05) |
| Rule 147 / 147A | Intrastate offering without concurrent federal registration (c12) |
| Rule 701 | Compensatory sales to employees, consultants and advisors; not for Exchange Act reporting companies (c13) |
Note also that the source lists Regulation Crowdfunding as operating through a registered broker-dealer or registered funding portal (c10), so the identity of the intermediary is part of the pattern to check, not an afterthought.
What the source does not say
The source page does not establish several things a reader might reasonably want, and this article does not fill those gaps.
- It does not define "accredited investor" or give any thresholds for that definition.
- It does not describe what counts as "reasonable steps to verify" accredited status under Rule 506(c) (c04).
- It does not set out the conditions or mechanics for obtaining a waiver of "bad actor" disqualification; the page raises the topic as a question (c14) rather than answering it.
- It does not state penalties for late or missed Form D filings, and it does not say whether any particular filing satisfies the 15 day timing (c06).
- It does not address state-level filing or notice requirements, digital asset classification, platform availability by state, or account eligibility rules.
Because the page is a high-level summary (c02), treat it as a map of what to check, not a substitute for the underlying rule text or for advice about a specific offering. The verification task it supports is narrow and concrete: identify the exemption named, compare the offering's described conduct to that exemption's stated conditions, and for Regulation D claims check the Form D timing described in the source.
Sources
Informational only. Not financial, legal or investment advice. Check the primary sources listed above before you act on anything here.